Worcester Reverses Course on Proposed Homeless Fines
City Manager Eric Batista explains the revised anti-camping ordinance and the philosophy behind Worcester’s approach to homeless outreach.
By-Staff
Photo- submitted / Graphic – Radio Worcester
Questions, Concerns, Opinions?
TEXT US! >> 774-364-8255
Worcester, MA –Worcester City Manager Eric Batista discusses the city’s revised anti-camping ordinance, which removes a previously proposed $25 fine while maintaining provisions to address homelessness through outreach and treatment referrals.
The revised ordinance remains subject to City Council approval, with a vote expected on December 1, according to The Worcester Guardian.
Batista explains the ordinance targets structured encampments—defined as tents or prolonged stationary belongings—rather than individuals simply sitting in parks, and emphasizes a philosophy of compassionate intervention when people cannot make rational decisions about their own safety.
Batista shared emotional stories of the Quality-of-Life team trying to convince people to avail themselves of city services, he said even as the temperature plunges some people say they want to stay on the street, “There were people still denying us, fighting us that they were not going to go in to the senior shelter or the shelter. And we had to, in some ways, be forceful and say, no, you’re going to die out here if you’re not come in… We don’t want to see them dying in our streets.” Hank talks about what some are saying, that Worcester is being too aggressive, “But you’re right, the pushback or what I have seen online or people who have come to the rail is that somehow this is such a cruel administration; this is such a cruel city. But is that the alternative then? I’m just going to leave someone alone… That doesn’t seem to be very compassionate.” Hank asks about the philosophy behind the ordinance and when can persuasion go over a line, the Manager says “Does it take 33 times? Does it take 57 times? What is that number? And the philosophy of, there are people who say, well, whenever they’re ready or our philosophy is, can we be a little bit more forceful in saying, look, you’re in a really tough situation. You need some care.”
Police Drones, Burncoat Schools and DCU Center Funding
The interview covers multiple city priorities including evaluation of drone surveillance for addressing reckless dirt bike and e-bike activity on streets; financial planning for the $800 million Burncoat Middle and High School construction project, with strategies to maximize interest income and manage debt service through 2052; and efforts to secure state funding for DCU Center renovations, noting the facility’s unique city-owned status compared to other Massachusetts convention centers and recent successful negotiations for $5 million in bond authorization.
How Other Cities Address Homeless Encampments
As Worcester moves away from proposed financial penalties for unauthorized homeless encampments, other similarly sized American cities are experimenting with different combinations of enforcement, education, street outreach, treatment referrals and housing placement.
The central question facing these communities is how to maintain public safety and access to public spaces while addressing the underlying causes of homelessness.
Rochester, New York | Outreach Before Enforcement
Population: Approximately 211,000
Rochester has transitioned from a primarily police-led response to a human services model. Its Homeless Outreach Team uses a six-phase engagement process emphasizing individual assessment, case management and access to services.
Encampment closures are considered a last resort and are conducted without arrests under the city’s reported approach. Personal belongings removed during closures may be stored for 90 days.
Spokane, Washington | Outreach With Enforcement
Population: Approximately 229,000
In July 2025, Spokane approved an ordinance making unauthorized public camping a misdemeanor while prioritizing engagement with individuals before issuing citations.
The city subsequently introduced coordinated street outreach teams and smaller shelters offering mental health services, addiction treatment, medical care and housing placement assistance.
Spokane reported that the percentage of individuals exiting its homeless services system into permanent housing increased from 22% in 2024 to 29% in 2025.
Tacoma, Washington | Financial Penalties and Treatment
Population: Approximately 219,000
Tacoma prohibits camping in designated areas surrounding schools, libraries, parks, shelters and waterways.
Violations can carry fines of up to $250, imprisonment of up to 30 days, or both. However, the city prioritizes voluntary compliance, shelter referrals and behavioral health services. Eligible offenders may be referred to specialized courts that connect participants with treatment and community resources.
How Worcester Compares
| Worcester, MA | Population: 206,000 |
|---|---|
| Financial penalties | Proposed $25 fine removed |
| Camping restrictions | Yes |
| Street outreach | Yes |
| Treatment referrals | Yes |
| Housing and shelter referrals | Yes |
| Criminal enforcement | Not established |
| Rochester, NY | Population: 211,000 |
|---|---|
| Financial penalties | Not emphasized |
| Camping restrictions | Encampment closures |
| Street outreach | Yes |
| Treatment referrals | Yes |
| Housing and shelter referrals | Yes |
| Criminal enforcement | Closures without arrests |
| Spokane, WA | Population: 229,000 |
|---|---|
| Financial penalties | Criminal citations possible |
| Camping restrictions | Yes |
| Street outreach | Yes |
| Treatment referrals | Yes |
| Housing and shelter referrals | Yes |
| Criminal enforcement | Misdemeanor |
| Tacoma, WA | Population: 219,000 |
|---|---|
| Financial penalties | Up to $250 |
| Camping restrictions | Yes |
| Street outreach | Yes |
| Treatment referrals | Yes |
| Housing and shelter referrals | Yes |
| Criminal enforcement | Misdemeanor |
Worcester’s comparison is based on Batista’s description of the revised ordinance in the Radio Worcester interview.
Measuring Success
While municipalities differ in their enforcement strategies, the effectiveness of these programs can be evaluated through several measurable outcomes:
-
Reduction in unsheltered homelessness.
-
Successful placement in permanent housing.
-
Acceptance of mental health and substance abuse treatment.
-
Reduction in recurring encampments.
-
Emergency shelter availability and utilization.
-
Municipal spending on enforcement versus services.
Removing an encampment does not necessarily mean that its occupants are no longer homeless. Whether individuals achieve lasting housing stability remains a separate measure of success.
The key distinction: All four cities incorporate outreach and assistance into their response to homelessness. Their approaches differ primarily in the use of financial penalties, criminal enforcement and compulsory compliance.
Sources
-
City of Tacoma: Encampment Policies and Procedures
HUD Homelessness and housing placement statistics
U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness Federal encampment policy guidance
National Alliance to End Homelessness Research and policy analysis
Massachusetts General Laws Legal authority for enforcement
U.S. Supreme Court City of Grants Pass v. Johnson (2024), legal context for camping restrictions
U.S. Census Bureau Population Data and Demographics
Editor’s Note: Artificial intelligence was used to assist with identifying comparable municipal policies and organizing background research. Policy details and sources were independently reviewed by Radio Worcester before publication.
LIVE STREAM
Radio Worcester
CONNECT
RADIO WORCESTER STUDIOS
Summit Street (Behind Polar Park)
Worcester, MA 01610.
LISTENER LINE
774-364-8255
MAIN OFFICE
774-364-8255