DOJ Investigation of Worcester Police Ends as Batista Details Police Reforms

DOJ Investigation of Worcester Police Ends as Batista Details Police Reforms

Batista: Worcester Police Reform Continues After DOJ Investigation

What Comes Next for Worcester Police?

By-Hank Stolz
Graphic-Radio Worcester

Questions, Concerns, Opinions?

TEXT US! >> 774-364-8255

Editors Note – While Worcester officials state that the DOJ has closed its investigation, the Justice Department’s public Special Litigation case page continued to list the Worcester Police Department matter as an ‘Investigation’ as of Aug. 14.

Worcester, MA- The U.S. Department of Justice investigation into the Worcester Police Department may be coming to an end, but City Manager Eric Batista says the city’s work to reform the department is continuing.

Appearing on Talk of the Commonwealth on Radio Worcester, Batista discussed changes made within the Worcester Police Department following the DOJ’s December 2024 findings, as well as the administration’s plans for accountability, accreditation and rebuilding trust with the community.

The DOJ opened its pattern-or-practice investigation in November 2022 to examine allegations involving excessive force and discriminatory policing. Its 2024 report raised concerns involving excessive force, sexual misconduct, racial disparities and the department’s systems for investigating and addressing misconduct.

Batista Points to Changes in Worcester Police Policies

Batista said Worcester has strengthened a number of department policies and practices over the past year.

“We’ve strengthened our policy. We’ve strengthened our sexual harassment policy. We’ve strengthened our policy on this level of work… And again, one of the biggest components of that now is body cameras.”

He also pointed to changes involving use of force and increased supervision.

“We’ve strengthened our use of force policies as well and made sure there’s more oversight of leadership in that department.”

The city previously released a detailed response outlining changes made following the DOJ report, including reforms involving sexual assault investigations and other police practices.

Rebuilding Trust Will Take More Than Body Cameras

Batista acknowledged that changes in policy do not erase the impact of the DOJ findings.

“We know that the fact remains that our community has been tremendously impacted by the findings issued in 2024. And we know that that will never change, that impact will never change.”

He said body cameras and other individual reforms can help, but argued that rebuilding trust ultimately depends on consistent leadership.

“Building trust with community is not just implementing one tool and hoping that that tool is going to be the piece that’s going to help build community trust.”

Batista said the larger challenge is changing institutional culture.

“Culture change in different organizations takes time. And so we’re committed to that.”

Why Batista Opposes a Civilian Review Board

The city manager also addressed the continuing debate over whether Worcester should establish a Civilian Review Board to provide additional oversight of the police department.

Batista remains opposed to creating one.

Instead, he pointed in part to the Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission, or POST Commission, and argued that its authority is sometimes overlooked in discussions about police accountability.

“POST, what POST has that nobody else has is they have the ability to decertify an officer. Nobody has that ability other than POST.”

Batista said Worcester has itself referred officers to POST for potential decertification.

“We as a city, we’ve made recommendations to POST to decertify officers. We’ve done that proactively and intentionally.”

The POST Commission was created under Massachusetts’ 2020 police reform law and oversees certification, discipline and training of peace officers. Its authority includes suspending, limiting, conditioning or revoking an officer’s certification.

The Civilian Review Board question remains contentious. Residents and advocates have continued to push for independent civilian oversight, while Batista’s administration argues Worcester’s existing oversight structure makes another board unnecessary.

Worcester Police Pursuing Accreditation

Batista said one of the most significant pieces of the department’s next phase is accreditation.

“I think one of the biggest things is the department’s going through an accreditation process. And that accreditation process requires the departments to strengthen policies, to strengthen practices.”

According to Batista, Worcester has completed the first phase and is continuing through the process.

“For us to obtain that accreditation, there’s ongoing work where we’ve gone through the first phase, we’re onto the next one, and we’re going to continue until we are fully accredited as a department.”

For Batista, the end of the federal investigation does not mean the end of scrutiny or reform.

The challenge now is whether the changes in policy, oversight and leadership translate into the long-term cultural change — and community trust — he says the administration is committed to achieving.

Statement from City Manager Eric D. Batista Regarding U.S. DOJ Investigation

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: 8/14/2026
MEDIA CONTACT: Kiernan Dunlop, DunlopK@worcesterma.gov

WORCESTER, Mass. – I understand that the decision by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) to close its investigation into the Worcester Police Department without further action has elicited a strong reaction across the city. My Administration felt it necessary to share such an important update with the community when we were notified by the DOJ. It’s unfortunate that our announcement has been mischaracterized, which distracts from the collective improvements and progress made since the 2024 report was released.

 

As I said at the time of the report’s release, the findings were both shocking and unacceptable. The report will leave a lasting impact on our community, and I acknowledge the hurt of those affected by such conduct and the concerns community members have. At the same time, I acknowledge the experiences of the men and women of the Worcester Police Department and how the perception of their dedication to protecting public safety was damaged by the report. While damaging, the report also pushed us to further enhance policies and systems of accountability.

 

As referenced in the DOJ’s letter, we were informed that the matter was being closed with no further action, based in part on a lack of current allegations concerning the conduct that was subject to the original investigation. The municipality’s announcement did not state that the DOJ retracted its findings, nor did it imply that the 2024 allegations were unfounded. To state otherwise only serves to further divide us.

 

I also want to reiterate my own commitment to accountability and reinforce the work of the Worcester Police Department and my Administration even before the 2024 DOJ report was released. To imply that I am aligned with any dismantling of civil rights protections is a gross distortion of the truth. In fact, the opposite is true, and the DOJ letter announcing the closure directly cites the accountability initiatives my Administration has implemented, including updated policies, training materials, body-worn cameras, and strengthened use of force review.

 

Since being appointed City Manager I have led with my core values of honesty and integrity. The closure of the DOJ investigation is not vindication, but it does reflect our progress and should be recognized. It also does not mark the end of our continuous improvement efforts, which will evolve for years to come. I promise you that I will not stop identifying ways to work as a community to keep building trust in our Police Department and in my Administration. I have been meeting with community members to discuss challenges, concerns, and solutions, and that work will continue. It is up to us to follow through on corrective action, and I look forward to discussing that further at Tuesday’s City Council meeting.

 

 

###

 

graphic for Explainer Sidebar

What Is the Massachusetts POST Commission?

The Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission is an independent state agency created as part of Massachusetts’ 2020 police reform law. It oversees certification, discipline and training standards for law enforcement officers throughout Massachusetts.

Unlike a municipal Civilian Review Board, POST has statewide authority over an officer’s professional certification. The commission can suspend, limit, condition or revoke certification and order retraining. Revocation of an officer’s certification is commonly referred to as decertification.

That distinction is central to Batista’s argument: Worcester can investigate or discipline its employees and can refer matters to POST, while POST has the power to prevent a decertified officer from continuing to serve as a police officer in Massachusetts.

LIVE STREAM
Radio Worcester

kill the ball media

CONNECT

RADIO WORCESTER STUDIOS

Summit Street (Behind Polar Park)
Worcester, MA 01610.

LISTENER LINE

MAIN OFFICE

Worcester City Manager Eric Batista Responds to WRRB Civilian Review Board Report

Worcester City Manager Eric Batista Responds to WRRB Civilian Review Board Report

Worcester City Manager Eric Batista Responds to WRRB Civilian Review Board Report

By-Hank Stolz

Photo-Radio Worcester

WORCESTER, MA– Worcester City Manager Eric Batista joined Hank Stolz on Talk of the Commonwealth to address the recently released Worcester Regional Research Bureau (WRRB) report recommending that the city establish a civilian police oversight board. The report, which Batista commissioned in partnership with the bureau, outlined fourteen recommendations for how such a board could be structured and operate effectively.

Batista explained that the effort began under the previous administration. “Many in the community and on the council wanted an independent analysis,” he said. “Rather than having the administration write it—which might be perceived as biased—it made sense to have the Research Bureau, as an objective third party, do a comprehensive review.”

Batista said the report contained no major surprises. “I’ve spent years studying civilian review boards and their impact,” he told Stolz. “I think it provides a solid foundation of information, and now I’ll work with departments to evaluate next steps.”

When asked whether a civilian review board could interfere with the city’s ongoing police reforms, Batista said the impact would depend on the model adopted. “Every community designs its board differently,” he noted. “What I can say is that our work with Chief Saucier and the equity office over the past few years has been transformative. We’re making structural, systemic changes—not just performative ones.”

Empowering the Human Rights Commission

Batista also addressed the role of the city’s Human Rights Commission (HRC), which some have suggested could serve as the oversight body. He emphasized that empowering the HRC had always been part of his plan.
“My intent from day one has been to strengthen the HRC within the limits of its ordinance,” he said. “There was some misunderstanding when I asked the HRC to pause police-related investigations until the Department of Justice and racial equity audit reports were released. My goal was coordination, not obstruction.”

He pointed out that the HRC’s jurisdiction focuses on civil discrimination cases and that its investigators now work closely with the city’s Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) Office. “We’ve added a third investigator so they can operate more effectively,” Batista said.

Advisory Board in the Works

Batista confirmed that Police Chief Paul Saucier has begun outreach to residents about forming a citizen advisory council, originally authorized by executive order under former City Manager Ed Augustus. The group would provide feedback on policy and community relations. “It hasn’t been finalized yet,” Batista said, “but the chief is building the framework.”

Batista plans to deliver his own report to the City Council soon, outlining his response to the WRRB’s findings, detailing current initiatives, and recommending next steps.

Preparing for Winter and Snow Operations

Turning to winter readiness, Batista said staffing and equipment improvements were a priority. “We’ve doubled our number of mechanics,” he said, noting that having more technicians ensures plow trucks can quickly return to service. “We’ve also held job fairs and purchased additional equipment to strengthen our snow operations.”

He added that contractor shortages are a statewide problem, with the number of private snowplow contractors declining about 10 percent annually. “We’re offering competitive pay tied to actual snow events,” he explained. “Our goal is simple: keep roads safe and open for everyone.”

Housing Development Momentum

On housing, Batista said Worcester is seeing steady progress across affordability levels. “In just a few weeks, we’ve celebrated ribbon cuttings and groundbreakings totaling nearly 700 new affordable units,” he said. “We’re preserving existing stock, supporting homeownership, and even exploring tiny home projects.”

He emphasized that the city’s approach must include variety. “We need movement in the housing market,” he said. “When higher-income earners move into luxury units, it opens up more moderately priced options. Worcester’s mix of affordable, market-rate, and senior housing shows that development momentum is strong.”

Spectrum Negotiations and Senior Discounts

Asked about the stalled Spectrum contract, Batista said talks continue but the city won’t settle for less than it deserves. “We’re not wavering from our demands,” he said. “We want a contract that benefits residents. All options are on the table if we don’t get fair terms.”

One major sticking point, Batista noted, is the senior discount. “We’re holding firm on that,” he said. “These discounts are disappearing nationally, but we know how vital they are to Worcester’s seniors.”

Holden Lawsuit and State Responsibility

Batista closed by confirming that Worcester has appealed its case with the town of Holden to the Supreme Court while also engaging in settlement discussions. “We believe the state bears responsibility,” he said. “Both cities have contracts with the Commonwealth, not with each other. The state owns part of the infrastructure, so it must honor its obligations to both communities.”

DOJ Investigation of Worcester Police Ends as Batista Details Police Reforms

Worcester City Manager Eric Batista joins Talk of the Commonwealth following the end of the U.S. Department of Justice investigation into the Worcester Police Department. Batista discusses changes to use-of-force and sexual harassment policies, body cameras, police accreditation, accountability and why he does not believe Worcester needs a Civilian Review Board.

Worcester City Manager Explains Civilian Review Board Decision

Worcester City Manager Eric Batista explains why his administration is not recommending a civilian review board, describing the city’s existing independent investigative process, research into national oversight models, and broader efforts to strengthen public trust in policing.

LIVE STREAM
Radio Worcester

kill the ball media

CONNECT

RADIO WORCESTER STUDIOS

Summit Street (Behind Polar Park)
Worcester, MA 01610.

LISTENER LINE

MAIN OFFICE

Worcester Research Bureau Recommends Civilian Police Oversight Board After 50 Years of Debate

Worcester Research Bureau Recommends Civilian Police Oversight Board After 50 Years of Debate

Worcester Research Bureau Recommends Civilian Police Oversight Board After 50 Years of Debate

By-Hank Stolz

Photo-File

WORCESTER, MA– The Worcester Regional Research Bureau’s long-awaited report on police oversight has ignited conversation across the city, revisiting a debate that has surfaced periodically for more than half a century. The report, commissioned by the City of Worcester, recommends the creation of a civilian review board to enhance transparency and strengthen public trust in local law enforcement.

Paul Matthews, Executive Director of the Research Bureau, joined Hank Stolz on Talk of the Commonwealth to discuss the findings alongside Senior Research Associate Joshua Boucher, who helped lead the study.

“This issue has been hotly debated for 50 years in Worcester,” Matthews said. “It’s an important topic not to rush — one that deserves thoughtful, deliberate analysis.”

Commissioned by the City

Matthews explained that the City Manager formally requested the Bureau to conduct a comprehensive review of civilian police oversight models. The Bureau, a nonpartisan 501(c)(3) organization, undertook months of research, including a review of local and national oversight models and consultation with city officials.

“It’s not common that our reports get this much attention,” Matthews said. “But when the research was ready, it was our duty to release it. We’re apolitical — our role is to inform the public so the next City Council can make informed decisions.”

A Half-Century of Repeated Calls

Boucher’s historical review revealed that calls for civilian oversight in Worcester date back to 1970, resurfacing repeatedly in 1993, 1998, 2000, 2008, 2015, and 2021. Each time, the idea gained traction, only to be set aside as other reforms took precedence.

“It’s almost like a cycle that repeats over and over again,” Boucher noted. “The same shape every time — requests, debate, delay.”

While the city’s Human Rights Commission has often become a flashpoint in these discussions, Matthews noted that the Commission was never formally structured or resourced to serve as an oversight body.

A Framework for Transparency

The new report does not prescribe a specific model but outlines 14 key features of effective oversight, drawn from best practices nationwide and guidance from the National Association of Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement (NACOLE). These include:

  • A sufficient and sustained budget to support investigations

  • Clear jurisdictional authority defining the board’s scope

  • Transparent reporting of findings to the public

  • Regular public updates and documentation of disciplinary recommendations

Boucher emphasized that most civilian review boards do not directly discipline officers but can make recommendations to the police chief and request formal responses explaining whether and why those recommendations were followed.

Acknowledging Recent Reforms

Matthews was quick to credit ongoing efforts under City Manager Eric Batista and the Worcester Police Department for implementing recent reforms, including those prompted by the Department of Justice review. The Bureau’s inclusion of police disciplinary data, he said, is meant to highlight those reforms, not undermine them.

“This is an opportunity to help the community understand that real change is underway,” he said. “Transparency can strengthen trust.”

Worcester in Context

The Bureau also compared Worcester’s current approach to other major New England cities — Boston, Cambridge, Springfield, Hartford, New Haven, and Providence — all of which have adopted some form of civilian oversight.

“We’re not inventing the wheel here,” Matthews said. “Providence might even be ahead of us on this one.”

Looking Ahead

While some may choose to dismiss the recommendation outright, Matthews believes the report’s purpose is to inform an open, transparent dialogue among policymakers and residents.

“This won’t be decided at the next council meeting,” he said. “It’s a process — and it should be.”

The full report, “Overdue for Civilian Oversight: A Pathway for Lasting Police Reform,” is available at wrrb.org.

Worcester City Manager Eric Batista Responds to WRRB Civilian Review Board Report

City Manager Eric Batista joined Hank Stolz on Talk of the Commonwealth to discuss the Worcester Regional Research Bureau’s civilian review board report, highlighting transparency, accountability, and systemic reform in city government. Batista also covered snow operation readiness, major housing developments, and the city’s ongoing negotiations with Spectrum.

Worcester Research Bureau Recommends Civilian Police Oversight Board After 50 Years of Debate

The Worcester Regional Research Bureau’s new report recommends the creation of a civilian police oversight board, reigniting a debate that has resurfaced in Worcester for more than 50 years. Executive Director Paul Matthews and Senior Research Associate Joshua Boucher joined Hank Stolz on Talk of the Commonwealth to explain why the Bureau believes now is the time for thoughtful, transparent reform.

Worcester Police Union Leaders Respond to DOJ Report on WPD Allegations

Rick Cipro, President, and Anthony Petrone, VP of Police Officials Local 504, respond to the DOJ report on the Worcester Police Department, emphasizing the union’s commitment to accountability, transparency, and questioning the report’s findings. They call for evidence-based reporting and discuss changes made within the department, including the implementation of GPS and body cameras. Cipro also questions why allegations of criminal behavior have not been moved to a criminal investigation.

LIVE STREAM
Radio Worcester

kill the ball media

CONNECT

RADIO WORCESTER STUDIOS

Summit Street (Behind Polar Park)
Worcester, MA 01610.

LISTENER LINE

MAIN OFFICE

Worcester Report Calls for Civilian Oversight Amid Skepticism Over Implementation

Worcester Report Calls for Civilian Oversight Amid Skepticism Over Implementation

Worcester Report Calls for Civilian Oversight Amid Skepticism Over Implementation

By Hank Stolz

Photo- file

WORCESTER, MA– The Worcester Regional Research Bureau, has released a report titled Overdue for Civilian Oversight – A Pathway for Lasting Police Reform. (www.wrrb.org/reports/2025/10/ov…ivilian-oversight/)

Tom Marino, Mark Henderson, Ben White and Hank Stolz discuss a new report from the Worcester Regional Research Bureau which recommended the creation of a civilian police oversight board. The conversation revolved around the report’s potential impact, with most speakers expressing significant skepticism about whether an effective board would actually be implemented. They debated the likelihood of political maneuvering to weaken the board’s power, drawing parallels to the city’s Human Rights Commission, which they argued had been rendered ineffective over time.

Tom Marino of the 016.com said he has been told that the acceptance of a watered-down civilian review board will be a political trade-off for the approval of a police drone program. All agreed that this report, done at the behest of the City Manager, will stimulate debate on a subject that has been stalled.

Mary Keefe–Ron Waddell Worcester Debate

Watch the 15th Worcester District Democratic primary debate between incumbent State Rep. Mary Keefe and challenger Ron Waddell, presented by Radio Worcester.

Clark Dean: Trees Key to Massachusetts Heat Resilience

Massachusetts has appointed Katie Schlick as its first heat resilience officer. Clark University Dean Lou Leonard tells Radio Worcester that expanding and maintaining urban tree canopies can reduce temperatures, protect public health and address disparities between affluent and lower-income neighborhoods.

DOJ Investigation of Worcester Police Ends as Batista Details Police Reforms

Worcester City Manager Eric Batista joins Talk of the Commonwealth following the end of the U.S. Department of Justice investigation into the Worcester Police Department. Batista discusses changes to use-of-force and sexual harassment policies, body cameras, police accreditation, accountability and why he does not believe Worcester needs a Civilian Review Board.

Would Speed Cameras Make Worcester Safer?

Should Massachusetts allow communities to use automated speed cameras? Hank Stolz, Ben White and Radio Worcester callers debate whether the technology could make Worcester streets safer—or open the door to expanded government surveillance.

Civil War Reenactment Comes to Asa Waters Mansion in Millbury

Nearly 100 Civil War reenactors are coming to Millbury for a three-day living history event at the Asa Waters Mansion. Chris Naff and reenactor Thomas Connell join Radio Worcester with details on the encampments, battle reenactment, artillery demonstrations, mansion tours and more.

Troy Siebels Named Interim Executive Director of Worcester Guardian

Former Hanover Theatre President and CEO Troy Siebels has been named interim executive director of The Worcester Guardian. Siebels tells Radio Worcester how the opportunity developed and why his new role will focus on relationships, partnerships and building financial support for independent local journalism.

LIVE STREAM
Radio Worcester

kill the ball media

CONNECT

RADIO WORCESTER STUDIOS

Summit Street (Behind Polar Park)
Worcester, MA 01610.

LISTENER LINE

MAIN OFFICE

Worcester to Release Redacted Police Misconduct Files to Human Rights Commission

Worcester to Release Redacted Police Misconduct Files to Human Rights Commission

Worcester to Release Redacted Police Misconduct Files to Human Rights Commission

worcester police

Worcester Human Rights Commission member Randy Feldman tells Talk of the Commonwealth that the Chief Diversity Officer for Worcester announced that the City Manager will release the redacted files of complaints on individual officers of the WPD to the commission. The Human Rights Commission has long sought police misconduct files. City Manager Eric Batista had previously denied the report’s release to the commission, citing the investigation from the DOJ and a diversity and equity analysis. Once completed, the redacted files will be given to the HRC, although the timeline is unclear. After reviewing the files, the HRC will then be allowed to make policy recommendations to the WPD. The WPD has asked the HRC for their input on two proposed policy changes when it comes to sexual assault investigations and how “stings” will be handled when it comes to prostitution.

Photo- file

LIVE STREAM
Radio Worcester

kill the ball media

CONNECT

RADIO WORCESTER STUDIOS

Summit Street (Behind Polar Park)
Worcester, MA 01610.

LISTENER LINE

MAIN OFFICE

Worcester to Release Redacted Police Misconduct Files to Human Rights Commission

Worcester Police Work Limits Under Scrutiny: Is 96 Hours Too Much?

Worcester Police Work Limits Under Scrutiny: Is 96 Hours Too Much?

worcester police

Worcester Police Officers can work 96 hours a week. Few do, but Randy Feldman, of the Worcester Human Rights Commission, is asking if that is too many hours. The Commission is requesting information so they can look at the subject, which is something Feldman says the WPD themselves originally asked for. On Talk of the Commonwealth, the question of whether this is common sense was raised. Feldman wonders if an overtired officer, who has to deal with the public, often in a stressful situation, can be at their best if they are working so many hours. Feldman wants to look not just at overtime but also at paid details. The Commission is receiving push back from those who say stick to homelessness and other issues and stop looking at the WPD.

Photo- WPD

LIVE STREAM
Radio Worcester

kill the ball media

CONNECT

RADIO WORCESTER STUDIOS

Summit Street (Behind Polar Park)
Worcester, MA 01610.

LISTENER LINE

MAIN OFFICE